There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear, because fear has to do with punishment. The one who fears is not made perfect in love. – 1 John 4:18
Since my last post, I took care to censor any comments concerning The UMC General Conference in St. Louis this week. I watched and read and texted friends, but I held off posting anything because I wanted to formulate my words carefully. Well, here is my story.
I was a religion major in college, and as part of my degree requirements, I was supposed to take an ethics class. At the end of the course, we were to write a paper on any ethical dilemma we wanted to choose. I chose to write my essay on a topic on something I was genuinely conflicted about: the ordination of gay clergy.
This was an issue that hit home for me because I was raised in the Presbyterian Church USA, which was deliberating that next year on the subject. PCUSA ultimately decided to accept gay clergy causing the expected split in the church.
I spent hours on my paper, trying to figure out what the PCUSA was on about with accepting LGBTQ people. I had not experienced many gay people, especially gay people of faith. When all was said and done, I turn in my passionate research paper with the following carefully worded conclusion:
‘…At this time, I cannot endorse the acceptance of LGBTQ people in church leadership.’
That was my honest opinion as a freshman in college, and, as God would have it, that was the same year a good friend of mine tearfully came out to me as gay.
I was one of the first people outside his family to know, and his family had not been taking it well. My friend, who was a devoted Christian, was sent by his parents to faith-based conversion therapy. He’d spent the better part of the summer in counseling in an attempt to make him straight. The result was depression, self-loathing, and the contemplation of suicide.
Eventually, he changed schools to put distance between himself and his parents, and we ended up drifting apart. The impact on our relationship left a lasting impression. I could see in him the strong presence of the Holy Spirit and passion for Jesus mixed with confusion and frustration over his sexuality.
Through our relationship, I learned more about faith and ethics than my any class had ever taught me. My mind changed, and I knew that God would never have intended my friend to go through such agony in deciding between faith and sexuality.
As God would have it, that was not the last person of faith who ‘came-out’ to me as gay or questioning their sexuality. Being affirming of a person’s sexuality and faith has been a critical part of my ministry, primarily as a minister to young people.
Needless to say, I was upset by the vote on Tuesday for the Traditional Plan which condemns LGBTQ leadership in the church and reinforces sanctions on those who officiate same-sex weddings. Although having studied Methodist polity and history, I also think a crucial problem for The UMC is conferencing on an international level (Dr. Jan Love has a great article on this.) It destroys the ability to contextualize ministry and follow the movements of the Holy Spirit.
I was also upset because a conservative hard line makes ministry with young people nearly a non-starter. Young people represented an overwhelming minority of people seated at the Genera Conference, so their voices were effectively silenced despite being the future of the church. (Bishop William Willimon also has a lot to say on this issue.) Moreover, I worry about my ability to minister to young people who are discovering their sexuality and increasingly more invested in diversity. I currently work in an area that offers very few options for LGBTQ people of faith and their allies, and I’m not sure where they would go.
However, I woke up on Wednesday filled with new hope for a few reasons. First, I know that my Methodist LGBTQ friends and those who are allies are devastated by the dark night of this decisions. I’ve been down this road before in the PCUSA, so I know there will be an end to this current season of suffering. Right now, people are hurting, but I know from personal experience that there will be a resolution. This General Conference has created some open wounds, but now real work can begin.
Second, I was marvelously encouraged by the outpouring of LGBTQ support that I saw on Social Media, within North Georgia leadership and in meetings in my local church. It warms my heart to see love and acceptance reaching out against exclusion and bigotry. Not everyone feels that way. I was addressed by some conservative-leaning people on Wednesday who wrongfully assumed I was as joyous as they were at the result of the vote. Regardless of your stance on the matter, I not sure celebration at the expense of another is the right response anywhere in the United Methodist Church right now. Nevertheless, my friends, leaders, and role models in ministry have responded in affirming love.
Finally, I feel hopeful because I see a kind of affirmation from Jesus in being on the “losing side.” Jesus, whose mantra was the “the first shall be last,” and “blessed are those who mourn” and “love your neighbor” and “take up your cross,” never promised that following him would be easy. If this current moment is a struggle, it means the convictions we are striving for are real and significant.
As I write this, our local church is preparing the for its first step in processing this vote, a service of prayer and communion. I know there will be many broken hearts and worried minds at their service. Yet, I know in my soul God is still working here.