“Jesus said to her, “Mary!” She turned and said to him in Hebrew, “Rabbouni!” (which means Teacher).”
“Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!””
John 20:16 & 28 NRSV
A couple of weeks ago, I received my first piece of mail in which the prefix “Rev.” appeared before my name. It was the first time I had ever seen it written, and it felt surreal.
Becoming commissioned and ordained in The United Methodist Church as an Elder is a challenging process. I love this denomination, but I felt especially challenged because I was not raised a Methodist.
Full disclosure, I was deferred in 2020 primarily due to my lack of theological clarity. I was so upset, but at the time was offered a position as a Local Pastor. In the UMC, a local pastor is a type of clergy with a few differences from Elders. When I was deferred, someone on the board told me not to worry. I’d still be called “Reverend.”
That got me thinking, how important is that particular title to me? How often is one even referred to as “reverend” or “pastor” or “minister.”
I ended up declining the Local Pastor position to focus on my new baby and stay safe during COVID. In retrospect, deferral was such a blessing for my family. I joined a study group of people trying to pass the theology requirement. Funnily enough, none of them had been raised Methodist.
Now that I see the “Rev.” appearing before my name, I’ve started to think about the many names we use for faith leaders. I can recall receiving new clergy and asking them, “what would you like us to call you? Rev. LastName? Pastor FirstName? Doctor? Father? Brother? Minister? FirstName only?
What we call our clergy helps them understand what we want them to do for us. The titles we choose to use conveys how we want that minister (ordained or not) to function in our lives.
Jesus’s disciples called him Rabbi for the vast majority of his ministry. It is the traditional title for a Jewish spiritual leader who operated among the people, which means teacher. At the time, spiritual leaders also had the titles of “Priest” if you worked in the Temple or “Scribe” if you preserved the Holy Texts. There were even a few “Prophets” and “Prophetesses,” and even one “Baptist” that we know of.
When Jesus appeared to Disciple Thomas in John 20, he used a rather unique title, “My Lord and My God,” making explicit what so many already felt in their hearts.
These titles matter because they illustrate the perceived nature of the relationships on behalf the person speaking. Jesus had always been “Lord” and “God” to those who followed him. But it makes an enormous difference to use these terms and recognize Jesus for who he really is!
When addressing unfamiliar clergy, I make sure to use the most formal title available to show respect. I go out of my way to do this for clergy of color or clergywomen, who have been routinely denied the respect they deserve from the church.
I’m thrilled to have “Rev.” appear in front of my name, but I don’t need it. I’d rather people call me whatever they’re comfortable calling me. I’d rather someone use a title or name that helps me understand what role I fill in their life. I am amazed at the power these names and titles hold in shaping our understanding of one another. And, I am in awe of the power in the name of Jesus Christ, my Lord, and my God.

My new surname is Newkirk which means “new church” in Dutch. In a way, our marriage represents the founding of a new community of faith. Our family is a new little church, faithful to God through times of blessing and times of struggle. I decided to change my name as marker of the new spiritual reality that we are entering into together.